What insurance industry problems need fixing?

This blog post has been written by the person who has mapped the insurance market in a clean and beautiful presentation

The insurance industry sits on US$300 billion in annual fraud losses while struggling with legacy systems that take 6-9 months to launch new products at costs reaching US$900,000 each.

Traditional insurers face a perfect storm of operational inefficiencies, rising customer expectations for digital experiences, and emerging risks like climate events and digital assets that current products don't adequately cover. Meanwhile, 80% of insurers cite internal process complexity as their biggest barrier to faster payments, while only 35% have advanced AI-driven fraud detection capabilities.

And if you need to understand this market in 30 minutes with the latest information, you can download our quick market pitch.

What are the biggest inefficiencies in claims processing and payout systems?

Claims processing remains trapped in manual workflows that create multiple failure points and customer frustration.

The most significant bottleneck occurs in fragmented back-end infrastructure where separate claims, finance, and treasury systems require manual workarounds. 80% of insurers cite internal process complexity as their primary barrier to faster payments, with 66% struggling to access funds in real-time—rising to 74% in the U.S. market specifically.

Traditional end-to-end processes force customers through multiple manual touchpoints: submitting paper forms, having agents re-key data into policy administration systems, and waiting for adjusters to manually validate documentation. This creates cycle times measured in weeks or months rather than the hours or days customers now expect from digital-first companies.

The financial consequences are severe. Legacy maintenance and error correction inflate IT budgets by up to 45%, while poor claims experiences put US$170 billion in premiums at risk over five years. Customer satisfaction reflects these inefficiencies—31% of claimants express dissatisfaction after home and auto claims, with 47% considering switching insurers due to slow settlements.

Developing and testing new policy products averages 6-9 months at costs between US$400,000-900,000 per product, making insurers slow to respond to emerging risks or customer needs.

Which insurance operations still rely on manual paperwork and legacy systems?

Four core operational areas remain heavily dependent on manual processes that create bottlenecks and operational risk.

Underwriting and pricing operations still involve human review of non-integrated spreadsheets for risk assessments. Policy administration handles renewals and endorsements through batch interfaces requiring manual reconciliations between systems. Distribution channels rely on agent portals that often require paper signatures and faxed documents, creating delays in policy issuance.

The most problematic area involves reinsurance and finance workflows, where manual approval processes between claims and finance teams create significant delays. Only 1% of insurers rate their claims-finance collaboration as "highly effective," highlighting the dysfunction in these critical operations.

Legacy codebases built on COBOL, RPG/400, and other monolithic Policy Administration Systems compound these problems. These systems impede real-time data exchange, require increasingly scarce technical talent, and incur rising maintenance costs that can consume nearly half of IT budgets.

The operational consequences include increased errors from manual data entry, compliance risks from difficulty adapting to evolving regulations, and delayed time-to-market for new products that hinders responsiveness to emerging risks.

If you want to build on this market, you can download our latest market pitch deck here

How have customer expectations shifted for digital insurance experiences?

Customer expectations have fundamentally shifted toward instant, transparent, and personalized digital experiences that mirror best-in-class e-commerce platforms.

What new insurance products are underserved in today's market?

Two major categories of emerging risks remain dramatically underserved: climate-related coverage and digital asset protection.

Parametric insurance for climate events represents a massive opportunity despite growing demand for coverage that triggers payouts based on objective weather metrics rather than traditional loss verification processes. This approach could solve coverage gaps in high-risk regions where traditional insurance has become unaffordable or unavailable, creating "insurance deserts" that threaten mortgage markets in parts of Florida and California.

Digital asset insurance shows even more dramatic underservice—only 3% of digital assets are currently insured, exposing a US$19 billion protection gap in losses since 2011. Few insurers offer tailored cyber and crypto custody policies, leaving premiums high at 0.5-5% for custody coverage and 5-10% for slashing and directors & officers protection.

Additional underserved areas include embedded insurance products that integrate seamlessly into e-commerce and fintech platforms, micro-coverage for gig economy workers, and usage-based policies that leverage IoT devices for real-time risk assessment. The regulatory environment is beginning to support innovation in these areas through sandbox programs and updated compliance frameworks.

Need a clear, elegant overview of a market? Browse our structured slide decks for a quick, visual deep dive.

What are customers' biggest complaints about insurance companies?

Customer complaints have evolved significantly between 2023 and 2025, shifting from basic service issues toward demands for digital-first experiences and product relevance.

How much money is lost to preventable fraud annually?

Insurance fraud represents a massive financial drain that current detection systems fail to adequately address.

Global insurance fraud across life, annuity, and property & casualty lines totals approximately US$300 billion annually according to Everest Group research. Property & casualty claims fraud alone accounts for US$30 billion in annual losses within the United States, representing a significant portion of industry profitability.

The detection failure rate is alarming—only 35% of insurers have deployed advanced AI-driven analytics for fraud detection, leaving the majority reliant on outdated rule-based systems that miss sophisticated fraud schemes. These legacy detection systems are particularly vulnerable to emerging AI-driven fraud methods including deepfakes and synthetic identity creation.

Root causes of detection failures include siloed data systems that limit access to internal and external fraud indicators, manual investigation processes that allow fraud to slip through during time-consuming claim reviews, and inadequate investment in modern detection technologies. The financial impact extends beyond direct losses to include increased investigation costs, legal expenses, and premium inflation that affects all policyholders.

The opportunity for fraud prevention technology providers is substantial, given that even modest improvements in detection rates could prevent billions in annual losses while providing clear ROI for insurance carriers.

If you want clear data about this market, you can download our latest market pitch deck here

Which parts of the insurance value chain are most ready for automation?

Several segments of the insurance value chain present immediate automation opportunities with clear technology pathways and strong ROI potential.

Which insurance market segments are growing fastest in 2025?

Four distinct market segments are experiencing accelerated growth driven by technological capabilities and changing customer needs.

Embedded insurance leads growth as partnerships with e-commerce and fintech platforms create seamless integration opportunities. This segment benefits from reduced distribution costs and improved customer experience by offering coverage at the point of purchase or transaction.

Parametric insurance products are expanding rapidly for climate risk management, offering predetermined payouts based on objective triggers like wind speed or precipitation levels rather than traditional damage assessments. This approach provides faster claim resolution and clearer coverage terms.

Cyber and digital asset insurance represents the fastest-growing niche despite low current penetration rates. Rising enterprise demand for cyber coverage combined with regulatory mandates for data protection drive significant premium growth. Digital asset custody and protocol insurance remain largely untapped markets with substantial upside potential.

On-demand coverage for the gig economy and IoT-enabled usage models creates new revenue streams by matching coverage precisely to risk exposure periods. This segment appeals to cost-conscious consumers who want to pay only for coverage when needed.

Looking for the latest market trends? We break them down in sharp, digestible presentations you can skim or share.

What regulatory changes could accelerate insurance innovation?

Current regulatory constraints significantly slow innovation adoption, but several policy shifts could unlock substantial market opportunities in 2026 and beyond.

Data privacy regulations currently limit the adoption of alternative data sources in underwriting, preventing insurers from leveraging social media, transaction patterns, and behavioral data that could improve risk assessment accuracy. Regulatory sandboxes for testing new data sources could accelerate innovation while maintaining consumer protection.

Capital requirements create barriers for insurtech startups that lack traditional balance sheet strength, limiting competition and innovation. Modified capital frameworks for technology-enabled insurers could level the playing field without compromising policyholder protection.

Fragmented cross-border regulations impede the scaling of parametric insurance solutions that could address global climate risks. Harmonized international standards would enable more efficient risk transfer mechanisms and broader product availability.

Future opportunities include regulatory sandboxes specifically for digital asset insurance, harmonized climate risk disclosure mandates that create consistent data standards, and incentives for modernizing legacy core systems through public-private partnerships. These changes could unlock billions in market value while improving consumer outcomes.

If you want to build or invest on this market, you can download our latest market pitch deck here

How are tech startups disrupting traditional insurance companies?

Technology startups and embedded insurance platforms exploit specific operational and customer experience gaps that traditional insurers struggle to address quickly.

Tech startups offer seamless, API-driven insurance integration directly into e-commerce checkout flows, eliminating the traditional application and underwriting delays. This approach captures customers at the moment of need while reducing distribution costs and improving conversion rates.

Embedded platforms exploit gaps in micro-coverage for digital assets and climate events by providing specialized products that traditional insurers avoid due to perceived complexity or limited scale. These startups leverage advanced analytics to underwrite non-traditional risks faster and more accurately than incumbents constrained by legacy risk models.

Distribution innovation focuses on eliminating intermediaries and reducing customer acquisition costs through direct digital channels. Startups achieve customer acquisition costs 40-60% lower than traditional agents by leveraging social media marketing, referral programs, and data-driven targeting.

Product innovation targets underserved segments like gig workers, digital nomads, and crypto investors with coverage designed specifically for modern lifestyles. Traditional insurers struggle to serve these segments profitably due to legacy systems designed for standardized risk profiles.

Wondering who's shaping this fast-moving industry? Our slides map out the top players and challengers in seconds.

What are the true costs of customer acquisition and service?

Customer acquisition and servicing costs represent major margin drains for traditional insurers, creating opportunities for more efficient approaches.

Average customer acquisition cost (CAC) for property & casualty insurance ranges from US$487 to US$900 per customer according to industry analysis from William Blair and Amra & Elma. This high CAC reflects the complex sales process, agent commissions, and marketing expenses required to educate customers about insurance needs.

Servicing costs through traditional service centers typically consume 1-2% of premium revenue, while agency-based models can require up to 40% of revenue for overhead and commissions. This dramatic difference highlights the cost advantage of direct digital service models.

Traditional insurers face additional margin pressure from high customer service costs, complex claim processing workflows, and legacy system maintenance expenses. Combined with typical property & casualty profitability margins of only 3-8%, these cost structures leave little room for competitive pricing or innovation investment.

Digital-first insurers achieve significantly lower unit economics by eliminating agent commissions, automating service functions, and leveraging data analytics for more efficient customer targeting. This cost advantage enables competitive pricing while maintaining healthy margins for growth investment.

How can behavioral data and wearables improve insurance pricing?

Behavioral data and alternative data sources enable more accurate risk assessment and personalized pricing that benefits both insurers and customers.

Telematics and wearables provide real-time behavioral insights for usage-based pricing in auto and health insurance. Safe driving patterns, exercise habits, and health metrics allow insurers to reward low-risk behaviors with lower premiums while identifying high-risk patterns early.

Social media and transaction data help refine risk models by providing additional signals about lifestyle, financial stability, and risk-taking behavior. This data can supplement traditional credit scores and demographic factors for more comprehensive risk assessment.

Leading insurtech companies like Lemonade, Root, and Oscar Health successfully leverage AI and alternative data signals for better risk selection and customer loyalty. These companies demonstrate how behavioral data can reduce adverse selection while improving customer satisfaction through more accurate pricing.

Implementation challenges include privacy regulations, customer consent requirements, and the need for sophisticated data science capabilities. However, insurers that successfully integrate behavioral data achieve competitive advantages through better risk selection, reduced claims costs, and improved customer retention.

Planning your next move in this new space? Start with a clean visual breakdown of market size, models, and momentum.

Conclusion

Sources

1. Insurance Thought Leadership - Outdated Infrastructure Delays Claims
2. Insurance Journal - PWC Perspective on Modernising Legacy Systems
3. Decerto - Integrating Insurance Software with Legacy Systems
4. Fintech Global - Navigating Insurance Challenges in 2025
5. Insurance Business Magazine - $244 Billion at Risk from Poor Claims Experiences
6. PR Newswire - Digital Insurance Research Predictions 2025
7. ZEX PR Wire - $19 Billion Digital Asset Insurance Void Report
8. Deloitte - Financial Services Call to Action
9. Everest Group - Battling Digital Age Insurance Fraud
10. Amra & Elma - Customer Acquisition Cost Statistics
11. Bolttech - Customer Acquisition Costs Insights
12. One Agents Alliance - The Case for Insurance Service Centers